American Elections, Political Representation, and the Will of the People
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.47611/jsrhs.v12i3.4846Keywords:
democracy, elections, electoral systems, voting, disenfranchisement, electoral college, gerrymandering, first-past-the-post, proportional representation, ranked-choice votingAbstract
The idea that a government’s legitimacy depends upon the consent of those governed is a central feature of most democracies. In a representative democracy, the people exercise power indirectly, through voting in elections. Consequently, elections may be regarded as the central institution of a representative democracy. In theory, elections strive to capture the will of the people and translate it into proportional political representation. Yet in practice, they often fail to do so. This paper will examine the main flaws with elections in the United States. First it will discuss issues related to disenfranchisement, which result in large segments of the population being excluded from vote and, thereby, from the democratic process. Then it will examine issues related to electoral systems themselves, such as gerrymandering and design flaws in the electoral college and first-past-the-post elections, which prevent the votes that get made from being translated into proportional influence in the government. Throughout the discussion, this paper will also identify and evaluate potential paths for reform that could resolve or mitigate these problems, improving the health of American democracy.
Downloads
References or Bibliography
“Americans Are United against Partisan Gerrymandering.” Brennan Center for Justice, 15 Mar. 2021, www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/americans-are-united-against-partisan-gerrymandering?emci=4dc2c652-6a00-ec11-b563-501ac57b8fa7&emdi=ea000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001&ceid=.
Amy, Douglas J. “COMMON CRITICISMS OF PR AND RESPONSES TO THEM.” FairVote, 20 Oct. 2022, fairvote.org/archives/common-criticisms-of-pr-and-responses-to-them/.
Atkinson, Nathan, and Scott C. Ganz. “The Flaw in Ranked-Choice Voting: Rewarding Extremists.” The Hill, 30 Oct. 2022, thehill.com/opinion/campaign/3711206-the-flaw-in-ranked-choice-voting-rewarding-extremists/.
Avery, Dan. “Gerrymandering: The Greatest Threat to Voting in America.” CNET, 29 Oct. 2022, www.cnet.com/news/politics/gerrymandering-the-greatest-threat-to-voting-in-america/.
“Bipartisan Poll Shows Strong Support for Redistricting Reform.” Campaign Legal Center, campaignlegal.org/update/bipartisan-poll-shows-strong-support-redistricting-reform. Accessed 23 May 2023.
“Block the Vote: How Politicians Are Trying to Block Voters from the Ballot Box.” American Civil Liberties Union, 24 Feb. 2023, www.aclu.org/news/civil-liberties/block-the-vote-voter-suppression-in-2020.
Borresen, Kelsey. “Why Isn’t Election Day a National Holiday in the U.S.?” HuffPost, 8 Oct. 2020, www.huffpost.com/entry/election-day-not-national-holiday-united-states_l_5f7c94c3c5b60c6bcc62be0e.
Budiman, Abby. “Key Findings about U.S. Immigrants.” Pew Research Center, 1 Dec. 2022, www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/08/20/key-findings-about-u-s-immigrants/.
“Can We Solve Gerrymandering?” Renew Democracy Initiative, 10 Sept. 2021, rdi.org/can-we-solve-gerrymandering/.
Cochrane, Emily, and Patricia Mazzei. “House Passes Bill That Could Pave the Way for Puerto Rican Statehood.” The New York Times, 15 Dec. 2022, www.nytimes.com/2022/12/15/us/politics/house-puerto-rican-statehood.html.
Cooper, Ryan. “There’s Only 1 Real Solution to Partisan Gerrymandering.” The Week, 18 Nov. 2021, theweek.com/republicans/1007226/theres-only-1-real-solution-to-partisan-gerrymandering.
Craig, Andy. “The Fatally Flawed National Popular Vote Plan.” The Cato Institute, 17 Nov. 2021, www.cato.org/blog/fatally-flawed-national-popular-vote-plan.
“Democracy.” Encyclopædia Britannica, 20 May 2023, www.britannica.com/topic/democracy.
DeSilver, Drew. “Turnout in U.S. Has Soared in Recent Elections but by Some Measures Still Trails That of Many Other Countries.” Pew Research Center, 1 Nov. 2022, www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/11/01/turnout-in-u-s-has-soared-in-recent-elections-but-by-some-measures-still-trails-that-of-many-other-countries/.
Dixon, Matt. “DeSantis Announces 20 Arrests Tied to Voter Fraud Charges.” POLITICO, 8 Aug. 2022, www.politico.com/news/2022/08/18/ron-desantis-voter-fraud-arrests-florida-00052753.
Drutman, Lee. “To End Gerrymandering, Change How We Elect Congress.” Time, 14 Feb. 2022, time.com/6147927/gerrymandering-congress-better-way-vote/.
Duffin, Erin. “State Population: United States 2022.” Statista, 3 Jan. 2023, www.statista.com/statistics/183497/population-in-the-federal-states-of-the-us/.
“Elections and Voting.” The White House, 12 July 2022, www.whitehouse.gov/about-the-white-house/our-government/elections-and-voting/.
Elving, Ron. “The Florida Recount of 2000: A Nightmare That Goes on Haunting.” NPR, 12 Nov. 2018, www.npr.org/2018/11/12/666812854/the-florida-recount-of-2000-a-nightmare-that-goes-on-haunting.
Fingerhut, Hannah. “Already-Low Voter Satisfaction with Choice of Candidates Falls Even Further.” Pew Research Center, 12 Sept. 2016, www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2016/09/12/already-low-voter-satisfaction-with-choice-of-candidates-falls-even-further/.
Fowler, Stephen. “Why Do Nonwhite Georgia Voters Have to Wait in Line for Hours? Too Few Polling Places.” NPR, 17 Oct. 2020, www.npr.org/2020/10/17/924527679/why-do-nonwhite-georgia-voters-have-to-wait-in-line-for-hours-too-few-polling-pl.
Franklin, Josh. “First Past the Post Voting: Our Elections Explained.” Colorado Common Cause, 20 Aug. 2020, www.commoncause.org/colorado/democracy-wire/first-past-the-post-voting-our-elections-explained/.
Garver, Rob. “Experts See Gridlock, Dysfunction Likely in Incoming Congress.” VOA, 20 Nov. 2022, www.voanews.com/a/experts-see-gridlock-dysfunction-likely-in-incoming-congress/6838134.html.
“Gerrymandering: California’s Latest Action Thriller Villain?” Los Angeles Daily News, 28 Aug. 2017, www.dailynews.com/2017/03/18/gerrymandering-californias-latest-action-thriller-villain/.
Grabenstein, Hannah. “Should 16-Year-Olds Be Allowed to Vote?” PBS, 20 Apr. 2018, www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/should-16-year-olds-be-allowed-to-vote.
Harfst, Philipp, et al. “Voting Strategically in Two-Vote Elections.” The Many Faces of Strategic Voting: Tactical Behavior in Electoral Systems Around the World, edited by André Blais et al., University of Michigan Press, 2018, pp. 150–77. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctvh4zhzr.11. Accessed 23 May 2023.
Herman, Alice. “Wisconsin’s Disabled Voters Face Barriers amid ‘Massive Confusion.’” The Guardian, 28 Mar. 2023, www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/mar/28/wisconsin-absentee-ballots-disabled-voters.
History.com Editors. “15th Amendment: Constitution & Voting Rights.” History.com, 2009, www.history.com/topics/black-history/fifteenth-amendment.
Hoban, Brennan. “Why Are Swing States Important?” Brookings, 21 Oct. 2016, www.brookings.edu/blog/fixgov/2016/09/28/why-are-swing-states-important/.
Horton, Jennifer, and Dakota Thomas. “Ranked Choice Voting: What, Where, Why & Why Not.” The Council of State Governments, 8 May 2023, www.csg.org/2023/03/21/ranked-choice-voting-what-where-why-why-not/.
Jackman, Simon. “Explainer: Gerrymandering and the 2018 Midterm Elections.” United States Studies Centre, www.ussc.edu.au/analysis/explainer-gerrymandering-and-the-2018-midterm-elections. Accessed 23 May 2023.
Just, Rachel Louise. “Legislation Aims to Have Michigan Join National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.” WWMT, 2 Mar. 2023, wwmt.com/news/local/national-popular-vote-interstate-compact-michigan-legislation-15-states-washington-dc-lansing-lawmakers-politics.
Kirkpatrick, Jeane J. “Democratic Elections and Democratic Government.” World Affairs, vol. 147, no. 2, 1984, pp. 61–69. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/20672013.
Kohli, Anisha. “Puerto Rico Independence Bill Passes in the House.” Time, 17 Dec. 2022, time.com/6242054/house-passes-bill-that-would-allow-puerto-rico-to-vote-on-its-statehood-or-independence/.
Lawson, Karl. “The Nader Effect.” Los Angeles Times, 1 Oct. 2008, www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2008-oct-01-le-wednesletters1.s2-story.html.
Author, and Colleen Fenn. “Interview on Voting & Electoral Systems.” 27 Apr. 2023.
Author, and Trish Monroe. “Interview on Voting & Electoral System.” 27 Apr. 2023.
Author, and Karen Cortes. “Interview on Voting & Electoral System.” 27 Apr. 2023.
Lerner, Kira. “Republicans Lead Charge to Ban Noncitizens from Voting in Local Elections.” The Guardian, 22 Dec. 2022, www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/dec/22/republicans-noncitizen-voting-ban-local-elections.
Liptak, Adam. “Supreme Court Invalidates Key Part of Voting Rights Act.” The New York Times, 25 June 2013, www.nytimes.com/2013/06/26/us/supreme-court-ruling.html.
Lopez, Ashley. “In the U.S., Some 4.6 Million People Are Disenfranchised Due to a Felony Conviction.” NPR, 25 Oct. 2022, www.npr.org/2022/10/25/1130622918/felon-voting-state-laws-disenfranchisement-rates.
Medzerian, David. “Barriers to Voting Have Huge Impact on Turnout, but Americans Overlook Their Effect.” USC News, 23 Aug. 2022, news.usc.edu/201731/barriers-to-voting-matter-but-americans-overlook-their-impact-study-finds/.
“Meng Reintroduces Legislation to Lower the Voting Age in America to 16 Years Old.” Congresswoman Grace Meng, 22 Mar. 2023, meng.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/meng-reintroduces-legislation-to-lower-the-voting-age-in-america-to-16-0#
“NATIONAL POPULAR VOTE INTERSTATE COMPACT.” UNC School of Government, 18 Apr. 2011, lrs.sog.unc.edu/bill/national-popular-vote-interstate-compact.
“Number of Children in the U.S. by Age 2021.” Statista, 18 Jan. 2023, www.statista.com/statistics/457786/number-of-children-in-the-us-by-age/.
Orbuch, Alexandra. “National Popular Vote: Circumventing the United States Constitution.” Princeton Legal Journal, legaljournal.princeton.edu/national-popular-vote-circumventing-the-united-states-constitution/. Accessed 23 May 2023.
Pfiffner, James, and Jason Hartke. “The Electoral College and the Framers’ Distrust of Democracy.” White House Studies, May 2003, pfiffner.gmu.edu/files/pdfs/Articles/Electoral%20College,%20WH%20Studies%20.pdf.
Pilkington, Ed. “America’s Flawed Democracy.” The Guardian, 16 Nov. 2020, www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/nov/16/america-flawed-democracy-five-key-areas.
Plaskett, Stacey. “The Second-Class Treatment of U.S. Territories Is Un-American.” The Atlantic, 11 Mar. 2021, www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/03/give-voting-rights-us-territories/618246/.
“Poll: Americans Overwhelmingly Reject Voting Rights for Undocumented Immigrants.” The Hill, 27 July 2018, thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/399016-poll-americans-overwhelmingly-reject-giving-voting-rights-to/.
Prokop, Andrew. “How Democrats Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Gerrymander.” Vox, 14 Apr. 2022, www.vox.com/22961590/redistricting-gerrymandering-house-2022-midterms.
Prokop, Andrew. “Why the Electoral College Is the Absolute Worst.” Vox, 7 Nov. 2016, www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2016/11/7/12315574/electoral-college-explained-presidential-elections-2016.
Radde, Kaitlyn, and Connie Hanzhang Jin. “The next Round of Counting Begins in Alaska. Here’s How Ranked-Choice Voting Works.” NPR, 22 Nov. 2022, www.npr.org/2022/11/22/1138422560/the-next-round-of-counting-begins-in-alaska-heres-how-ranked-choice-voting-works.
Rakich, Nathaniel, and Tony Chow. “Illinois May Be the Worst Democratic Gerrymander in the Country.” FiveThirtyEight, 6 May 2022, fivethirtyeight.com/videos/illinois-may-be-the-worst-democratic-gerrymander-in-the-country/.
Ramos, Elliott. “There’s a Plan Afoot to Replace the Electoral College, and Your State May Already Be Part of It.” NBC News, 10 Nov. 2020, www.nbcnews.com/politics/2020-election/map-national-popular-vote-plan-replace-electoral-college-n1247159.
Ridley-Castle, Thea. “How Many Countries around the World Use Proportional Representation?” Electoral Reform Society, 20 Mar. 2023, www.electoral-reform.org.uk/how-many-countries-around-the-world-use-proportional-representation/.
Robinson, Jeffery. “The Racist Roots of Denying Incarcerated People Their Right to Vote.” American Civil Liberties Union, 27 Feb. 2023, www.aclu.org/news/voting-rights/racist-roots-denying-incarcerated-people-their-right-vote.
Rodriguez, Barbara. “Ranked-Choice Voting Is Gaining Momentum. so Are Efforts to Stop It.” The 19th, 8 May 2023, 19thnews.org/2023/04/ranked-choice-voting-election-system/.
Saad, Lydia. “Americans Call for Term Limits, End to Electoral College.” Gallup.Com, 5 Dec. 2022, news.gallup.com/poll/159881/americans-call-term-limits-end-electoral-college.aspx.
Sanders, Eric. “What Is Duverger’s Law?” The Center for Election Science, 20 May 2019, electionscience.org/commentary-analysis/voting-theory-what-is-duvergers-law/.
Schneer, Benjamin. “A Partisan Solution to Partisan Gerrymandering: The Define-Combine Procedure.” Harvard Kennedy School, 1 Aug. 2022, www.hks.harvard.edu/publications/partisan-solution-partisan-gerrymandering-define-combine-procedure.
Scommegna, Paola. “U.S. Has World’s Highest Incarceration Rate.” Population Reference Bureau, Aug. 2012, www.prb.org/resources/u-s-has-worlds-highest-incarceration-rate/.
Serwer, Adam. “Make Wisconsin a Democracy Again.” The Atlantic, 8 Apr. 2023, www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/04/wisconsin-republican-two-third-majority-gerrymandering/673659/.
Sheffield, Matthew. “Poll: 69 Percent of Americans Say Prisoners Shouldn’t Be Allowed to Vote.” The Hill, 9 Mar. 2022, thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/441863-poll-69-percent-of-voters-say-prisoners-shouldnt-be-allowed-to/.
“The Constitution of the United States: A Transcription.” National Archives and Records Administration, www.archives.gov/founding-docs/constitution-transcript. Accessed 23 May 2023.
Tracinski, Robert. “Why It’s Time to Raise the Voting Age Back to 21.” The Federalist, 1 Mar. 2018, thefederalist.com/2018/02/27/time-raise-voting-age-back-21/.
Uggen, Christopher et al. “Locked out 2022: Estimates of People Denied Voting Rights.” The Sentencing Project, 23 Nov. 2022, www.sentencingproject.org/reports/locked-out-2022-estimates-of-people-denied-voting-rights/.
US Census Bureau. “Participation in Congressional Elections by Sex since 1978.” Census.Gov, 8 Oct. 2021, www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2020/comm/participation-congress-election.html.
Vasilogambros, Matt. “Noncitizens Are Slowly Gaining Voting Rights.” Stateline, 1 July 2021, stateline.org/2021/07/01/noncitizens-are-slowly-gaining-voting-rights/.
“Voting Age Status Report.” National Youth Rights Association, 20 Apr. 2023, www.youthrights.org/issues/voting-age/voting-age-status-report/.
“Voting Rights: A Short History.” Carnegie, Nov. 2019, www.carnegie.org/our-work/article/voting-rights-timeline/.
Wagner, Markus, et al. “Voting at 16: Turnout and the Quality of Vote Choice.” Electoral Studies, June 2012, www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4020373/.
“What Is the Electoral College?” National Archives and Records Administration, www.archives.gov/electoral-college/about. Accessed 23 May 2023.
“What Is the Law on Faithless Electors?” Library of Congress, ask.loc.gov/law/faq/331082. Accessed 23 May 2023.
“Which States Split Their Electoral Votes?” Electoral Vote Map, 11 Mar. 2019, electoralvotemap.com/which-states-split-their-electoral-votes/.
Wines, Michael. “North Carolina Gerrymander Ruling Reflects Politicization of Judiciary Nationally.” The New York Times, 28 Apr. 2023, www.nytimes.com/2023/04/28/us/north-carolina-supreme-court-gerrymander.html.
Wines, Michael. “What Is Gerrymandering? And How Does It Work?” The New York Times, 27 June 2019, www.nytimes.com/2019/06/27/us/gerrymander-explainer.html.
“Why We Need to Fix the Electoral College.” Citizens Take Action, 24 Feb. 2022, citizenstakeaction.org/why-fix-the-electoral-college/.
“Wyoming 2020 Election Results.” CNN, edition.cnn.com/election/2020/results/state/wyoming. Accessed 23 May 2023.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Copyright (c) 2023 Gyuhong Lee; Bob Naeher
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright holder(s) granted JSR a perpetual, non-exclusive license to distriute & display this article.
